OK, I've been busy and procrastinating, but finally carved out a bit of time for this post. I have been SO frustrated shooting this camera, not because of the camera, but because of the learning curve. I went from being a fairly OK photog with my limited equipment to being a blind squirrel searching for a nut and sucking at it with the new gear. The advice on this thread has been wonderful... thanks again to Peter for starting it and to everyone for contributing.
After several frustrating dives I whittled my goals down to very simple - I wanted to shoot subjects from 2-3' away and have them turn out more or less decent. I'll work on macro later... Taking some of the advice here I set the camera on this dive at F5.6, iso 200, and a shutter speed of 1/160. I have a single, older Olympus strobe (UFL-1) - a bit underpowered and not much onboard adjustment. Basically I have manual and TTL, and half power and full power. The strobe has a diffuser on it. Some of the pics I zoomed in some - the idea being to get closer but not over power the subject. These were all shot with the strobe set on manual as I couldn't make the TTL work satisfactorily, and I just wanted to get a picture that didn't make me hit the delete key.
Below are a couple of keepers. All I've done to them is some brightness or contrast adjustment:
It was difficult to find the "sweet spot". My pics were either over or under exposed. I'm sure I would benefit from a more adjustable strobe? I also positioned the strobe above and directly over the subject - not as much sideways shadow (which looked "funny" to me) that way. Having background lowered the backscatter... shots with open water background seemed to have more backscatter.
The above pics have the subject positioned horizontally so the smaller depth of field isn't as noticeable (except in the first Copper Rockfish, which was HUGE). I am assuming that the shallow depth of field is because of the F5.6?
Any and all suggestions, input, criticism are most welcome. I'll try and post a few more.